Featured

Corona Diaries 12: The Illusion Of Numbers, Peaks & Plateaus

By
Akshaya Mishra

“Statistics are like a drunk with a lamppost: used more for support than illumination.” The quote attributed to Sir Winston Churchill, former British Prime Minister, appears apt in the context of chaos of numbers that the pandemic has unleashed. The words sound less cynical than those attributed to his predecessor separated by a century, Benjamin Disraeli, who is supposed to have said: “There are three kinds of lies: lies, damn lies and statistics”. But both point to the inadequacy of sets of numbers to reflect the truth in its entirety as well as their pliability.

Now cutting to the chase, a few questions. Do the numbers on Covid-19 illuminate us about the disease or do they confuse us more? Do they support theories that are not tenable under harsher scientific scrutiny? Numbers when controlled by governments are susceptible to manipulation. They may doctor numbers or weave false narratives around them with perfectly good intent or spurious ones. In time of a health crisis it is perhaps justified. Are we being fed with numbers that would keep our spirits high? Numbers, being numbers, are reductive and have clear limitations. They don’t grasp all dimensions, particularly the subjective ones, of the reality. Even if they are totally honest, they may still understate the reality. Do we get a definitive understanding of the pandemic looking through the prism of numbers? Here are few facts to consider.

OF PEAKS & PLATEAUS

The last these words were discussed with some intensity was in geography classes in school days ages ago. Corona has brought them back in circulation. Health experts in all countries have been speculating about Covid-19 cases hitting a peak and plateauing. Why, even US President Donald Trump announced a couple of days ago that the US has passed the peak. This despite there being no respite in number of deaths and a flood of new positive cases.

So what exactly do the words mean? The idea behind ‘peak’ is once the numbers eventually reach the highest point, it will be a steady decline thereon. ‘Plateau’ means the point from which there is no further rise. Even if deaths and fresh cases happen, they remain within a certain band for a stretch of time before declining. Frankly, neither makes logical sense. With the spread of the contagion not fully mapped yet estimates of both can only be witchcraft with data.

An opinion piece in The Guardian puts it this way: “Talk of the ‘peak’ can be misleading, because it’s not clear whether you are talking about Matterhorn or the Table Mountain — both have a summit but the peak is far more pronounced in one than the other…Worse, there maybe a mountain range. In other words, what is happening right now could be just one peak – not the peak…” The article emphasises the point that ‘this pandemic is only just getting started’ and ‘we nowhere near controlling coronavirus’.

One hopes the article is entirely off the mark, but the fact remains that ‘peaks’ and ‘plateaus’ are at best wishful constructs loaded more with hope than reason.

TESTS & THE NUMBER ILLUSION

If the comparison of infection and casualty numbers is lulling us into the complacency that we are better placed than people in other geographies hence need no additional precaution, lets be warned: numbers can be deceptive. Statistics, the popular quote goes, are like bikinis. What they reveal is interesting, but what they conceal is crucial. In the case of corona numbers what could be staying concealed in wonderful pie diagrams, tables and infographics could be matter of life and death. What is it?

Before we go there, the troubling query: Are we comparing apples with oranges? The critical element behind the numbers we get is the number of tests. How can we compare the results of a country or state conducting, say 10,000 tests per a million population during a specific period to one conducting 500 tests in the corresponding period? Any comparison with such fundamental discrepancy can only be misleading. Excelsheet extrapolations will only throw up flawed projections because there are just too many variables in case of Covid-19.

Coming back to the question what is getting concealed, it is possibly the real picture. It may not be deliberate, but that’s how it stands.

THE INFORMATION CHAOS

The number of corona deaths is depressing indeed. At the time of writing this piece, it stood at more than 1,50,000 worldwide with the USA leading the chart. We don’t know the real number, but what we know for sure is the deluge of patients is far beyond the intake capacity of healthcare systems in all countries. So the numbers of the affected or dead are only those who find place in the medical records. There could be people getting affected at homes, shantytowns and elsewhere and losing the fight before being treated. That would make the numbers much higher. The same goes for the number of people with the infection but without symptoms. But let it pass; the topic is too unpleasant.

The message here is: let’s be careful about how we read the numbers. The gloomy statistics of disaster elsewhere should have a sobering impact on us. The best is to learn from the experience of others. The response of countries where the virus spread earlier could serve as a guide for India. Information is key in this battle.

Akshaya Mishra

Senior Journalist & Writer based in New Delhi

Recent Posts

Three Killed After Google Map Leads Their Vehicle To Unfinished Bridge

Bareilly: Blind trust on technology can be detrimental too. That’s exactly what happened to three…

November 25, 2024

Soon After Parliament’s Winter Session Begins, Rajya Sabha Adjourned Amid Opposition’s Ruckus Over Adani Issue

New Delhi: The Winter Session of Parliament commenced on Monday (Nov 25). But both houses…

November 25, 2024

Bangladeshi Girl ‘Trafficking’ Case In Odisha: Couple Arrested For Forcing Her Into Prostitution

Cuttack: After rescuing a minor Bangladeshi girl, Madhupatna Police in Odisha’s Cuttack city have arrested…

November 25, 2024

2nd Maharashtra Tigress Zeenat Released Into Core Area Of Similipal In Odisha

Baripada: Ten days after being put in a soft enclosure inside Similipal Tiger Reserve (STR)…

November 25, 2024

Odisha GDP Suspends Jonk Police Station IIC For Dereliction Of Duty

Nuapada: Inspector In-Charge (IIC) of Jonk police station in Odisha’s Nuapada district, Gurudev Karmi, has…

November 25, 2024

IPL Auction: KKR Break Bank For Venkatesh On Lucrative Day For Indian Players; Check Top Buys

Mumbai: The first day of the IPL mega player auction at Jeddah threw up several…

November 24, 2024

Odisha Govt Hands Over Case Of Attack On Dharmasala MLA To Crime Branch

Bhubaneswar: The Odisha government has handed over the investigation into the attack on Dhramasala MLA…

November 24, 2024

Commissionerate Police Issues Traffic Advisory During Winter Session Of Odisha Assembly; Details Here

Bhubaneswar: The Commissionerate of Police on Sunday issued an advisory for movement of vehicular traffic…

November 24, 2024