Legal

Sex In Case Of Breach Of Marital Promise Is Not Rape, Rules Orissa High Court

By
OB Bureau

Cuttack: In a significant verdict, the Orissa High Court has observed that if a relationship goes sour and a person decides not to marry the partner, sex that preceded should not be considered rape.

The High Court’s observation came while considering a petition challenging the legality of criminal proceedings initiated under Sections 420, 376 and 354 in a case where a relationship had gone sour after seven years.

Terming the act as dissimilar to having sex under the false promise of marriage, Justice R K Pattanaik said, “There is a subtle difference between breach of promise, which is made in good faith but subsequently could not be fulfilled, and a false promise to marriage. In the former case, for any such sexual intimacy, an offence under Section 376 IPC (sexual assault) is not made out, whereas, in the latter, it is, since the same is based on the premise that the promise to marriage was false or fake from the very beginning, which is given on the understanding by the accused that it would be broken finally.”

A sour relationship, if initially started and developed genuinely with friendship, should not always be branded as a product of mistrust and mischief, thereby accusing the male partner of rape, the HC observed.

From the FIR and material evidence, it is observed that there was no genuine promise from the accused. It could not be established that the promise was fake and meant to induce the partner to obtain his/her consent to maintain sexual relationship, It said.

Therefore, it would not be an act in bad faith and an offence under Section 376 IPC could not be made out, Justice Pattanaik ruled in a recent order.

As per the case records, the woman had entered into a relationship with the petitioner which was built upon a friendship at a time when she was not yet divorced from her husband. A promise by the petitioner was broken, though he had initial interest and inclination to marry the woman, who, for certain reasons was not ready for it at that point of time.

Noting that the parties were aware of the consequences, the court said the parties are educated and well placed and were quite aware of the consequences and still engaged themselves in a relationship which remotely appear to be one sided and having understood the kind of relationship it was developed and had become later on, the court reaches at a conclusion that it would not be justified to allege rape against the petitioner.

OB Bureau

Recent Posts

Another Stone Falls From Jagannath Temple At Khallikote In Odisha’s Ganjam

Berhampur: A stone weighing 2 kg fell from the ‘Singhadwara Gumuta’ of the Lord Jagannath…

November 14, 2024

Sunita Williams Dismisses Rumours About Weight Loss, Explains Her ‘Sunken Cheeks’

New Delhi: Recent pictures of Space Station Commander Sunita Williams from the International Space Station…

November 14, 2024

Payal Rohatgi Calls Out Rupali Ganguly For Dating A Married Man

Mumbai: Actress Rupali Ganguly recently filed a Rs 50 crore defamation case against her stepdaughter…

November 14, 2024

National Hockey: Odisha To Clash With Manipur In Semifinals

Chennai: Odisha will face Manipur in the semifinals of the 14th Hockey India Senior Men’s…

November 14, 2024

India To Push Canada For Extradition Of Arrested Khalistani Terrorist Arsh Dalla

New Delhi: India will again ask Canada for the extradition of designated Khalistani terrorist Arshdeep Singh…

November 14, 2024

School Dropout From West Bengal Arrested For Practising As Ayurvedic Doctor In Odisha’s Berhampur

Berhampur: Police have arrested a man from West Bengal for allegedly claiming himself to be…

November 14, 2024

Manoj Bajpayee Recalls Staying In ‘Hell’, Experiencing Starvation

Mumbai: Carving a niche for himself in Bollywood was not a cakewalk for ‘The Family…

November 14, 2024

After Disapproving Of Ranveer, Mukesh Khanna Rejects Tiger Shroff For ‘Shakitmaan’

Mumbai: Mukesh Khanna’s Indian superhero series ‘Shaktimaan’ has been making headlines for quite some time…

November 14, 2024