Featured

Taunting Wife, Not Letting Her Watch TV Is Not Cruelty, Rules Bombay HC; Reprieve For Accused Family

By
OB Bureau

Mumbai: Taunting a wife, not allowing her to visit temples alone or making her sleep on a carpet cannot be considered as “cruelty” under IPC Section 498A, Bombay High Court has ruled.

Among other allegations against a man and his family were taunting the woman for the food she cooked, not allowing her to interact with neighbours or watch TV, reported LiveLaw.

The accused were convicted under IPC sections 498A and 306 (abetment to suicide) as their actions allegedly led to the woman’s suicide in 2002.

Convicted by a trial court in 2004, the accused had appealed to the high court.

The high court’s order noted that the deceased woman was not allowed to throw garbage alone and also asked to fetch water at midnight. Such allegations of “cruelty” cannot be considered as “severe” under the concerned section, as it concerned the domestic affairs of a household, the bench said.

Hence, it cannot be considered an offence under law.

The bench reasoned that cruelty, which can be either mental or physical, is “relative” and cannot be used in a “straitjacket” manner.

“Merely sleeping on carpet also would not amount to cruelty. Similarly, what sort of taunting was made and by which accused is not getting clear. Likewise, preventing her to mix with neighbours also cannot be termed as harassment,” Justice Abhay S Waghwase stated in his order.

Based on the testimony by witnesses and woman’s in-laws, the high court concluded that the allegations could not be considered as an immediate cause of suicide.

“They (mother, uncle and aunt of deceased) have admitted that, there was no communication from the deceased either written or oral, she has not conveyed that there were any instances of cruelty in proximity to suicide. There is no evidence to show that at that relevant point or any proximity to the suicide, there was any demand, cruelty or mal-treatment so as to connect them with the suicidal death. What triggered the suicide has remained a mystery,” the court said.

Criticising the trial court’s “out of place” observations while convicting the accused 20 years ago, the high court judge said there was no evidence to prove that the conduct of accused towards the deceased was “incessant or consistent”.

OB Bureau

Recent Posts

Baba Siddique Murder Accused Used Mobile Hotspot To Evade Arrest, Here’s How

Mumbai: The Mumbai Police crime branch revealed that an accused in the Baba Siddiqui murder…

November 22, 2024

Kashika Misra Wins Golf Championship; Know About Her Odisha Roots

Bhubaneswar: Kashika Misra has created history by becoming the first Odia girl to win any…

November 22, 2024

Moscow Entitled To Strike Military Targets Of Countries That Allow Ukraine To Use Weapons…: Putin’s Warning To ‘West’

Moscow: President Vladimir Putin has warned the countries that allow Ukraine to use their weapons…

November 22, 2024

4 Held From Gujarat 5 Months After Duping Elderly Odisha Couple Of Rs 34L In ‘Digital Arrest’

Bhubaneswar: After a five-month-long investigation, Jharsuguda police in Odisha busted an inter-state cybercrime racket and…

November 22, 2024

Vedanta Expands Its ‘Swarna Prashan’ Drive In Odisha’s Rayagada & Kalahandi

Bhubaneswar: Vedanta Aluminium has expanded its ‘Swarna Prashan’ initiative, an Ayurveda-based immunisation drive, to over…

November 22, 2024

Justin Trudeau Govt Denies Linking PM Modi, Jaishankar & Ajit Doval To Criminal Activities In Canada

Ottawa: The government in Canada, led by Justin Trudeau, on Friday denied linking Prime Minister…

November 22, 2024

Two Sisters Consume Poison In Odisha’s Boudh, One Dead

Bhubaneswar: A woman died while her younger sister is battling for life after an alleged…

November 22, 2024

Achyuta Samanta Conferred Lifetime Achievement Award At 43rd World Congress Of Poets

Madurai: Founder of KIIT, KISS, and KIMS, Achyuta Samanta has been honoured with Lifetime Achievement…

November 22, 2024