City

Cannot Stall Promotion Indefinitely Over Pending Cases: HC To Odisha Govt

By
OB Bureau

Cuttack: The Orissa High Court, in 11 separate but identical judgments, ruled that promotion of an employee by the departmental promotion committee (DPC) cannot be withheld awaiting conclusion of disciplinary proceeding or criminal proceeding indefinitely.

While considering the cases of four civil engineers, two police officers, one clerk, one agriculture engineer, one food supplies & consumer welfare officer and two civil service officers against whom criminal proceedings have been drawn, the single judge bench of Justice Sibo Sankar Mishra directed the state government to give promote them from the date their juniors and batch-mates got such promotion.

Though the DPC had recommended their case for promotion years ago, in some cases over 10 years, sealed cover procedure has been adopted owing to the pendency of the criminal prosecution against them. “This is nothing but adding insult to the injury, “ Justice Mishra observed, while adding that “Unexplained prolongation of criminal trial violates the constitutional rights of an accused and denial of statutory or any other rights.”

While chargesheets have been filed, the trial of the proceedings is moving in the snail’s pace. In one case for 19 years, and in two cases for 24 years.

The high court, however, maintained that in case of conviction their promotion would be revoked.

It is worth mentioning here that the then Chief Justice Dr S Muralidhar and Justice G Satapathy in May held that government employees facing trial in criminal cases are not entitled to get either regular or ad-hoc promotion. The court had then cited a Supreme Court judgment (April 27, 2017) which ruled that there was no right of the government servant to be considered for promotion during the pendency of either departmental proceedings or criminal proceedings or both against such government servant.

“It is clarified that as and when the criminal proceedings end in favour of the government servant by way of an acquittal and such government servant also stands exonerated from the departmental proceedings then notwithstanding the superannuation of such government servant, the notional benefits attaching to the promotion that is due to the government servant would be calculated and the pension fixed accordingly, the order concluded.

OB Bureau

Recent Posts

CDPO In Odisha Caught Taking Rs 12K Bribe From Anganwadi Staffer

Bhubaneswar: The Odisha Vigilance sleuths on Wednesday apprehended Child Development Project Officer (CDPO) of Ganjam's…

November 27, 2024

Petition In Bangladesh High Court Seeks Ban On Iskcon, Attorney General Dubs It As ‘Religious Fundamentalist’ Body

Dhaka: The Bangladeshi government on Wednesday called Iskcon or the International Society for Krishna Consciousness…

November 27, 2024

Andhra Pradesh Deputy CM Seeks UN Intervention Into Alleged Attacks On Hindus In Bangladesh After Chinmoy Krishna Das’ Arrest

New Delhi: Condemning the arrest and denial of bail to Hindu monk Chinmoy Krishna Das…

November 27, 2024

Odisha To Adopt National Education Policy In Schools By 2025: Minister

Bhubaneswar: After adopting it in higher education, the Odisha government is now gearing up to…

November 27, 2024

Did Shinde Demand Home Ministry, If Not Maharashtra CM Post?

Mumbai: Amid the continuing suspense over a new Maharashtra Chief Minister, reports claimed that the…

November 27, 2024

2 Held For Duping Sarpanch, Lawyers By Posing As Police Officers In Odisha’s Malkangiri

Malkangiri: Two persons were arrested for allegedly duping people in Odisha’s Malkangiri district by posing…

November 27, 2024

Gautam Adani, His Nephew & Vneet Jaain Not Charged In Bribery Case: Former Attorney General Of India Defends Billionaire

New Delhi: The Adani Group on Wednesday strongly dismissed allegations of bribery and violations of…

November 27, 2024

Odisha IAS Officer Sujata Karthikeyan Joins Duty After Rejection Of Leave Extension Application

Bhubaneswar: Senior IAS officer Sujata Karthikeyan, wife of V K Pandian, joined duties on Wednesday…

November 27, 2024