India

SC Overturns 34-Year Decision, Says States Can Rule On ‘Industrial Liquor’

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Wednesday ruled that state governments can legislate on the sale of ‘industrial alcohol’, otherwise called ‘denatured spirits’, by including it under the term ‘intoxicating liquor’ in the State List, i.e., the list of subjects on which states can pass laws.

Eight members of the Chief Justice DY Chandrachud-led nine-judge Constitution Bench found in favour of petitioning states – led by Uttar Pradesh and including Maharashtra, Bengal, and Kerala – while the ninth, Justice BV Nagarathna, dissented. The majority ruled that the term ‘intoxicating liquor’ cannot be understood to mean only that fit for human consumption. Instead, it will include all liquids that contain alcohol, even if not meant for human consumption, can be included in the term ‘intoxicating liquor,’ NDTV reported.

The Chief Justice said states’ power to legislate could not be challenged since the law covers ‘intoxicating’ and ‘industrial’ products, and that the union could not take over this subject. The majority ruling overturned a 34-year decision by a seven-judge bench in Synthetics and Chemicals Pvt Ltd vs State of Uttar Pradesh. It was referred to a nine-judge bench in 2007.

Justice BV Nagarathna, however, ruled on the principle that ‘industrial alcohol’ means it is not fit for human consumption, and that there was a “lack of competence for the state legislature”. She said the decision in the Synthetics case had been “correctly decided by this court”.

The verdict had been reserved in April after a marathon six-day hearing. In that hearing, petitioners argued that if the power to regulate ‘industrial alcohol’ goes to the centre, their hands would be tied when dealing with illegal consumption of ‘industrial alcohol’.

OB Bureau

Recent Posts

‘Pushpa 2’ Stampede: We Don’t Have The Strength To Fight, Says Victim’s Husband

Hyderabad: Bhaskar, husband of the 35-year-old woman who died in the Sandhya Theatre stampede in Hyderabad,…

5 minutes ago

Vigilance Nabs Marketing Inspector While Taking Bribe From Contractual Staff In Odisha’s Koraput

Koraput: Vigilance has apprehended a Marketing Inspector for taking a bribe of Rs 7,000 from…

15 minutes ago

Legendary Filmmaker Shyam Benegal Passes Away After Prolonged Illness

Mumbai: Legendary filmmaker Shyam Benegal breathed his last at Wockhardt Hospital in Mumbai on Monday.…

28 minutes ago

Fadnavis Slams Rahul For ‘Killed Because He Was Dalit’ Statement On Parbhani Custody Death

Mumbai: Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis on Monday came down heavily on Leader of Opposition Rahul…

36 minutes ago

Odisha: 15th Mayurbhanj Heritage Walk Explores Budha Raula Temple & Monastery In Baripada

Baripada: More than 60 participants took part in the 15th edition of the Mayurbhanj Heritage Walk…

42 minutes ago

[Watch] Fateh Trailer: Netizens Call It Sonu Sood Starrer Desi ‘John Wick’

Mumbai: The makers of the Sonu Sood starrer ‘Fateh’ released a thrilling, action-packed trailer of…

1 hour ago

This website uses cookies.