Legal

Supreme Court Cracks Down On Media Trials, Wants Govt Guidelines In 3 Months

By
OB Bureau

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Wednesday took strong exception to ‘media trials’ and directed the Union Home Ministry to prepare guidelines for police to follow during press briefings in relation to criminal cases. The ministry has three months prepare a detailed manual.

The apex court was referring to “biased reporting that gives rise to public suspicion that the person has committed an offence”, reported NDTV.

Underlining the need to sensitise police personnel, a bench headed by Chief Justice DY Chandrachud directed top police officers of each state and the National Human Rights Commission to submit suggestions to the Home ministry within a month.

“Administration of justice is affected by ‘media trials’. Need to decide at which stage (of investigation) details should be disclosed. This is a very important issue because it involves interests of victim and accused. It also involves the interest of the public at large… media report on crime-related matters involves many aspects of public interest,” the Supreme Court said.

“At a basic level fundamental right to speech and expression is directly involved in the context of both the media’s right to portray and broadcast ideas and news… but we should not allow ‘media trial’. People have the right to access information. But if important evidence is revealed during the investigation, the investigation can also be affected,” the court argued.

In 2017, the top court had asked the government to frame rules for police briefings keeping in mind rights of the accused and victim, and to ensure rights of both sides are not prejudiced or violated in any way.

Hearing a petition relating to the 2017 instruction, the CJI-led bench said today:

“The accused, whose conduct is under investigation, is entitled to a fair and unbiased investigation… at every stage, every accused is entitled to presumption of innocence. Media reportage that implicates an accused is unfair.”

Six months ago, the CJI urged journalists to maintain ‘standards of accuracy, impartiality and responsibility in reporting.’

“Selective quoting of speeches and judgments has become a matter of concern. This practice has a tendency to distort public’s understanding of important legal issues. Judges’ decisions are often complex and nuanced, and selective quoting can give the impression a judgment means something different from what the judge intended,” the court said.

Additional Solicitor General Aishwarya Bhati, appearing for the Centre, assured the court that the government will frame and release guidelines regarding media briefings by the police.

OB Bureau

Recent Posts

Naveen Patnaik Slams Odisha Govt Over Mango Kernel Deaths In Kandhamal

Bhubaneswar: Mounting a scathing attack on the BJP government in Odisha, Biju Janata Dal (BJD)…

November 7, 2024

Vessel Carrying Over 60 Passengers, Bus Stuck In Odisha’s Chilika Lake

Puri: A vessel carrying a bus and over 60 passengers got stranded in Chilika lake…

November 7, 2024

Ration Card Holders In Odisha To Get Both Wheat & Rice From January: Minister

Bhubaneswar: The Odisha government has taken necessary steps for providing Odisha will get wheat to…

November 7, 2024

CM Says People Will Get Justice At Doorsteps In Odisha Amid Plan For ‘Gram Nyayalayas’ In Blocks

Bhubaneswar: Odisha Chief Minister Mohan Charan Majhi on Thursday asserted that the state government is…

November 7, 2024

Delhi High Court Refuses To Lift Chhath Puja Celebration Ban In Yamuna As Devotees May Fall Sick

New Delhi: The Delhi High Court on Wednesday refused to lift the ban on Chhath…

November 7, 2024

Royal Scions Attack Rahul Gandhi Over ‘Pliant Maharajas’ Remark

New Delhi: Members of royal families across India have condemned Congress leader Rahul Gandhi for…

November 7, 2024

Mumbai Police Arrests Lawrence Bishnoi’s Brother Bikaram For Death Threat To Salman Khan

New Delhi: The Mumbai Police arrested a man from Karnataka for sending a threat message…

November 7, 2024

Youth Attacked By Mob Over Facebook Post In Presence Of Police In Odisha’s Ganjam

Berhampur: A youth was critically injured after being thrashed by an angry mob over a…

November 7, 2024