India

Supreme Court Reserves Order On Hijab Ban Case

By
OB Bureau

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Thursday reserved its verdict on the petitions challenging the ban on wearing hijab in schools in Karnataka after 10 days of arguments before the bench.

“Now it is time for us to do our homework and reading,” remarked the bench of Justices Hemant Gupta and Sudhanshu Dhulia while reserving its verdict. More than 20 lawyers, including senior advocates Rajiv Dhavan, Kapil Sibal, Salman Khurshid, Devdatt Kamat, and Sanjay Hegde, among others, submitted arguments on behalf of the petitioners.

The government was represented by Solicitor General (SG) Tushar Mehta, ASG KM Nataraj, and Karnataka Advocate General Prabhulinga Navadgi.

The court granted time to the petitioner’s lawyers to give rebuttal arguments against the stand taken by the government.

Senior advocate Dushyant Dave, who represents the Muslim petitioners, criticised the solicitor for bringing up the “irrelevant” issue of the PFI’s involvement and the “conspiracy” to incite street protests, India Today reported.

Quoting an order passed by a different bench of the Supreme Court on Wednesday over sensationalism and hate speech in the media, Dave argued that the submissions made by the SG had “created prejudice” when the issue before the court was constitutional rights.

Dave also argued that the state had the “right to renounce its own circular.” Dave and other petitioners had submitted a circular issued by the Karnataka Education Department in 2021, which clearly stated that uniforms are not mandatory in government PU colleges and that any mandatory uniforms imposed by the college administration could attract punishment.

“The SG has said their own guidelines are unsubstantiated arguments. Their own affidavit gives the guidelines for 2022, which says uniforms are not compulsory. How are they disowning their own guidelines?” questioned Dave.

Senior advocate Huzefa Ahmadi also argued that “no cogent reason is given for how wearing hijab will impair education or discipline.”

Arguments were also submitted by senior advocates Salman Khurshid, Devdatt Kamat and Sanjay Hegde for rebuttal.

The issue involves the interpretation of whether the hijab is an essential religious practice of Islam and also constitutional law questions the right to freedom of conscience, culture, privacy, and dignity.

The Muslim petitioners have also argued that since it is an issue of interpretation of religion and the scope of the government’s power to regulate religious practice, it should be referred to the nine-judge bench set up for the Sabarimala and other religion-gender issue cases.

With Justice Hemant Gupta scheduled to retire on October 16 this year, the verdict in the matter is expected before his retirement date.

OB Bureau

Recent Posts

Driver Dead, Over 30 Passengers Injured As Bhubaneswar-Bound Bus Overturns In Nayagarh

Bhubaneswar: Driver of a bus died and over 30 passengers sustained injuries as the vehicle…

November 8, 2024

Rupee Falls To All-Time Low Of 84.37 Against US Dollar

New Delhi: The rupee fell 5 paise to an all-time low of 84.37 against the…

November 8, 2024

[Watch] How BJP MLAs Were Marshalled Out Of J&K Assembly Again Amid Ruckus Over Article 370 Restoration

Srinagar: For the third day in a row, the Jammu and Kashmir assembly on Friday…

November 8, 2024

Royal Bengal Tiger Caught On Camera Crossing NH 16 Near Berhampur; Leopard Rescued From Poachers’ Trap

Berhampur: A video of a Royal Bengal Tiger (RBT), which was spotted crossing the National…

November 8, 2024

Indian-Origin Woman Buys House ‘Friends’ Star Matthew Perry’s LA House, Performs ‘Puja’

New Delhi: Anita Lallian, a real estate developer and film producer with Indian roots has…

November 8, 2024

Maha Snana Ritual Underway In Odisha’s Maa Tara Tarini Temple Post Theft

Berhampur: Maha Snana ritual will be conducted at Tara Tarini Temple, allegedly desecrated by thieves…

November 8, 2024

Religious Body Demands Ban On Shop Allotment To Non-Hindus At Mahakumbh Mela In Uttar Pradesh

Allahabad: A Hindu religious body, Akhil Bhartiya Akhara Parishad, has reportedly demanded that no shops…

November 8, 2024

Aligarh Muslim University Entitled To Minority Status: Supreme Court

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Friday overturned its 1967 order that said the Aligarh…

November 8, 2024