Legal

Woman Can’t Allege Rape After Six Years Of Consensual Sex: Karnataka HC

By
OB Bureau

New Delhi: Citing it as a classic illustration of abuse of the process of law, the Karnataka HC quashed two criminal cases filed against a Bengaluru man by a woman, alleging breach of promise of marriage after being in a relationship for six years.

It is not one, two, three, four or five, but six years of consensual physical/sexual relationship between the petitioner and the complainant after having met through a social media platform. The complaint narrates all details… The allegation that is made later is, from Dec 27, 2019, the intimacy between the two waned. Fading away of the intimacy after 6 years of consensual acts of sexual intercourse cannot mean that it would constitute ingredients of rape, it said, according to a Times of India report.

Pointing out that the sexual relationship lasted six long years, the judge said it cannot but be construed that it would not be rape for it to become punishable under section 376 of IPC. “If further proceedings are permitted to continue, it would run foul of (a) plethora of judgments rendered by the Supreme Court on the issue,” the judge said, citing the Supreme Court judgment in Pramod Suryabhan Pawar vs State of Maharashtra case and a few other cases.

The petitioner had befriended the complainant through Facebook in 2013. According to her, since he was residing close by, she was always taken to his house on the pretext that he was a very good chef. He would prepare delicious food and every time she used to go to his house, drink beer and have sexual intercourse. After having a physical relationship with her on the promise of marriage for about six years, the petitioner broke the said promise. On March 8, 2021, she registered a complaint with Indiranagar police alleging cheating and criminal intimidation, among other things. Later, when she learnt that the petitioner, after getting bail, was living in Davanagere, the complainant went there and registered a complaint of assault and rape based on the same set of allegations. Another woman too was named along with the petitioner in the second complaint. The police had filed chargesheets in both cases.

The petitioner, along with the co-accused woman, challenged the proceedings. He alleged that the complainant is in the habit of making friends with the affluent, extract money and blackmail them by registering crimes. He also cited another case where the complainant had a physical relations with a man and then registered a similar case against him before the Airpo police station in Bengaluru, alleging breach of promise of marriage and rap among other things. The court was told that the man was acquitted in 2016 the woman turned hostile and reversed her statement.

OB Bureau

Recent Posts

Another Stone Falls From Jagannath Temple At Khallikote In Odisha’s Ganjam

Berhampur: A stone weighing 2 kg fell from the ‘Singhadwara Gumuta’ of the Lord Jagannath…

November 14, 2024

Sunita Williams Dismisses Rumours About Weight Loss, Explains Her ‘Sunken Cheeks’

New Delhi: Recent pictures of Space Station Commander Sunita Williams from the International Space Station…

November 14, 2024

Payal Rohatgi Calls Out Rupali Ganguly For Dating A Married Man

Mumbai: Actress Rupali Ganguly recently filed a Rs 50 crore defamation case against her stepdaughter…

November 14, 2024

National Hockey: Odisha To Clash With Manipur In Semifinals

Chennai: Odisha will face Manipur in the semifinals of the 14th Hockey India Senior Men’s…

November 14, 2024

India To Push Canada For Extradition Of Arrested Khalistani Terrorist Arsh Dalla

New Delhi: India will again ask Canada for the extradition of designated Khalistani terrorist Arshdeep Singh…

November 14, 2024

School Dropout From West Bengal Arrested For Practising As Ayurvedic Doctor In Odisha’s Berhampur

Berhampur: Police have arrested a man from West Bengal for allegedly claiming himself to be…

November 14, 2024

Manoj Bajpayee Recalls Staying In ‘Hell’, Experiencing Starvation

Mumbai: Carving a niche for himself in Bollywood was not a cakewalk for ‘The Family…

November 14, 2024

After Disapproving Of Ranveer, Mukesh Khanna Rejects Tiger Shroff For ‘Shakitmaan’

Mumbai: Mukesh Khanna’s Indian superhero series ‘Shaktimaan’ has been making headlines for quite some time…

November 14, 2024