New Delhi: Former US President Joe Biden has accused Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of repeatedly promising to reduce civilian deaths in Gaza, but failing to follow through. In his new memoir, Biden says Netanyahu was more focused on protecting his political position than on Israel’s long-term future.
The comments appear in advance extracts from ‘Promise Me, America’, which will be released on November 17. Biden writes that, after Hamas’s October 7, 2023 attack on Israel, he repeatedly asked Netanyahu to take stronger steps to protect Palestinian civilians during Israel’s military campaign.
According to Biden, Netanyahu knew that the rising death toll was damaging Israel’s image around the world and reducing support for the war in the United States. But Biden says the Israeli leader’s promises were rarely matched by action.
“Bibi had no qualms about making promises he had no power – or intention – to keep,” Biden writes.
The extracts were published by CNN and other US outlets on Friday, revealing the deep tension between the two leaders who had known each other for many years, as reported by NDTV.
Biden says Hamas’s October 7 attack destroyed his hopes of achieving lasting peace in the Middle East. He recalls calling Netanyahu several times on the day of the attack to make clear that the United States wanted to prevent anything similar from happening again.
“I wanted him to know my determination to ensure that a day like this would never happen again,” Biden writes.
Promises, Then More Deaths
Biden says he understood why Israel wanted to respond after the Hamas attack. But he says he began urging Israeli leaders almost immediately to do more to protect civilians caught in the fighting.
“I had been calling on Israel to take precautions to reduce civilian suffering since the beginning of the conflict,” Biden writes. “I had expressed these concerns privately in many conversations with Bibi, who acknowledged the damage that these rising casualties were doing to Israel’s image, and to US support for the war.”
Biden says Netanyahu appeared to understand that the growing number of Palestinian deaths was hurting Israel globally and creating political problems for the United States. Yet, according to Biden, that understanding did not lead to a lasting change in Israeli military actions.
“But a familiar pattern established itself: He would promise to do more, and then another aggressive action would follow, killing more civilians. When we called them on it, the Israelis always had an explanation or excuse, but the result was the same,” Biden writes. “While I understood that he was working under severe pressures, I was frustrated by his failure to think like a statesman and safeguard Israel’s long-term interests, not just his own short-term political needs.”
Little Trust Between Them
Biden also describes his relationship with Netanyahu as tense and built on limited trust. He says the two men could speak openly, but did not fully rely on each other.
“There wasn’t much trust between us,” Biden writes. “He and I could be direct with each other, but there wasn’t a ton of trust. I was also concerned about Bibi’s tendencies, which were similar to Trump’s. He could be extremely flexible with the facts and had no hesitation about bending democratic institutions to serve his personal interests.”
The memoir’s account comes as Gaza continues to face a devastating human cost. Nearly 75,000 Palestinians, including children, have been killed, according to figures from Gaza’s Health Ministry cited by the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA). Almost the entire population has been displaced at some point during the conflict, while the United Nations has described Israel’s campaign as genocide.















