New Delhi/Bhubaneswar: The Supreme Court has set aside acquisition of agricultural land in three villages of Sundargada district in Odisha for a cement plant, holding that mandatory consent of the Gram Sabha and affected families had not been obtained.
The apex court held that prior consent of the Gram Sabha is mandatory under the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013.
A Bench of Justices Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma on Wednesday overturned the Orissa High Court’s September 2024 judgment upholding the acquisition of land in Kukuda, Bihabandha and Lanjiberna villages for the cement company. The HC judgment had treated the consent requirement as directory rather than mandatory.
The SC bench ruled that failure to obtain such consent under Section 41(3) of the Act vitiates the entire acquisition process.
A submission on behalf of Dalmia Cement stated that the provisions of Section 41(3) of 2013 MMDR Act are merely directory and not mandatory, as the Gram Sabha cannot be a body to override the consent of the landowners.
However, the bench said the statutory requirement could not be diluted once the govt decided to proceed with acquisition in Scheduled Areas. “Therefore, we hold that the requirement of Section 41(3) of the Act is mandatory in nature, and there is nothing to suggest it to be directory or advisory,” the bench observed.
The SC delivered the judgment on the appeal filed by Bibol Toppo and others, residents of the three villages, challenging the land acquisition undertaken for Dalmia Cement’s mining expansion
Since the acquisition was for a private company, consent of at least 80% of affected families under Section 2(2)(b) was necessary, along with the Social Impact Assessment (SIA), before the government considered the proposal.
Taking serious note of the absence of consent, the court pointed out that the two Gram Sabhas concerned had actually rejected the acquisition proposal through resolutions passed on January 26, 2020. The authorities, however, proceeded with the acquisition despite the opposition.
“Unfortunately, the impugned judgment has the effect of reducing a mandatory statutory requirement into a paper formality. What is more concerning is that the present case is on an even worse footing. Far from a meaningful consent, there is not even paper consent of Gram Sabha in this case,” the SC said.
The SIA exercise was also flawed as no actual public hearing was conducted and a company-linked adviser was included in the expert group, raising concerns over its independence.
It further held that Section 41(3) of the Act imposed an additional requirement of prior Gram Sabha consent because the land fell within a Scheduled Area covered by the Fifth Schedule to the Constitution.
Quashing the acquisition proceedings and related notifications and orders, the Supreme Court left the State at liberty to initiate fresh acquisition proceedings in accordance with law, subject to obtaining genuine Gram Sabha consent, the consent of at least 80% of affected families and conducting a legally compliant SIA.
Welcoming the Supreme Court verdict, national convenor of Lok Shakti Abhiyan Prafulla Samantara urged the government to cancel all mining leases and land acquisition done without consent of Gram Sabha.
He said the administrative officers responsible for violation of law for acquisition of land for the cement company should be punished. The company has to restore the land for cultivation as soon as possible and compensation must be paid to the owners of land for loss of livelihood, Samantara said.













