New Delhi: The Supreme Court, on Monday, dismissed a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) challenging the government’s E20 or ethanol blending plan. Under this plan, the government is working towards blending all petrol sold in the country with 20% ethanol by 2025-26.
The Bench of Chief Justice of India B R Gavai and Justice K Vinod Chandran struck down the plea after Attorney General R Venkataramani argued against the plea, seeking ethanol-free petrol for pre-2023 vehicles.
During the hearing senior advocate Shadan Farasat, appearing for the petitioner, referred to a 2021 NITI Aayog report that expressed concern about six per cent reduced fuel efficiency for older vehicles – specifically those manufactured before 2023 – running on the blended petrol.
“We have to be given an option… we are not against E20 but at least let suppliers inform us as some vehicles are not compliant with the same. Only vehicles post-April 2023 can tolerate E20,” the petitioner submitted.
The petitioner acknowledged E20 is a “logical progression as far as fuel is concerned” and said he was not contesting the higher blend, but only challenging “non-availability of E10 petrol.
The AG countered by calling the petitioner a ‘name-holder’ for a ‘huge lobby’ with vested interests. He claimed E20 would benefit sugarcane farmers and save foreign exchange.
“Will people outside the country dictate what kind of fuel India should use?”
The E20 blend push has led to objections from car owners and auto enthusiasts who believe the mix will adversely affect engine performance and mileage, causing more mechanical issues and a reduction in the overall lifespan and reliability of their cars.
The government has refuted such claims and said that E20 is safe and does not affect the performance of vehicles. It also added that the move would not only reduce pollution and save money on oil imports, but result in better acceleration and ride quality.
“A study on life cycle emissions of Ethanol done by NITI Aayog has said that GHG (greenhouse gas) emissions in case of use of sugarcane and maize-based ethanol are less by 65% and 50%, respectively than those of petrol,” the Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas said.
Ethanol blending averaged 12.06 per cent in 2022/23 and rose to 14.6 per cent the next year. By February this year, it had reached 19.6 per cent. The 20 per cent mark was crossed soon after.
After hearing both sides, the Court dismissed the PIL.
