New Delhi: The Supreme Court, on Friday, dismissed an appeal by the Karnataka government against the Karnataka High Court decision allowing bike taxi services to operate in the state.
This decision by the top court will be cited across the country whenever any state government attempts to stop the operation of bike taxi services.
The ruling was passed by the bench of Justice Satish Chandra Sharma and Justice N Kotiswar Singh.
Justice Sharma recounted a conversation he had with young women working in his office who used bike taxis, while pronouncing the verdict.
“I asked them, how do you come to my office? They said on a motorbike because they do not have the money to hire a cab. I asked them, why don’t you take an auto? They said, ‘Sir, it is five times (the fare),” Justice Sharma remarked, as reported by Bar and Bench.
A division bench of the Karnataka High Court, on January 23, had effectively lifted a court-ordered ban on bike taxi services in the state.
A single judge of the Court had earlier ordered that bike taxi services be halted until the state comes out with a policy permitting the same. This ruling was challenged in appeals filed by Ola, Uber, Rapido, motorcycle owners and the Bike Taxi Welfare Association.
The division bench of Chief Justice Vibhu Bakhru and Justice C M Joshi had allowed the appeals.
The Court had held that motorcycles can be registered as transport vehicles and operated as contract carriages while allowing the appeals. It ruled that the state could impose regulatory conditions but could not refuse permits merely because the vehicle was a motorcycle.
he High Court division bench directed the authorities to consider applications for registering motorcycles as transport vehicles and grant permits to operate them as bike taxis.
The Karnataka government subsequently approached the Supreme Court, raising concerns over passenger safety, insurance coverage and the absence of adequate safeguards for bike taxi passengers.
The government was joined by five auto and taxi driver associations, who challenged the High Court ruling, contending that permitting bike taxis without comparable regulatory obligations would adversely affect existing transport operators.
The Supreme Court dismissed the appeals, thereby permitting the continuation of bike taxi services in the state.
The Supreme Court had questioned the state’s concerns over traffic congestion during the hearings, noting that motorcycles occupied less road space than cars. It also highlighted the affordability of bike taxis.
Motorcycles and motor cabs were separately defined under the Motor Vehicles Act and that its aggregator rules did not envisage bike taxis, the state has argued.
Aggregators had no inherent right to operate such services, it maintained, citing a 2019 expert committee report that examined safety, congestion and pollution concerns.
The state also expressed willingness to consider permitting bike taxis elsewhere in Karnataka, but maintained its opposition to operations in Bengaluru.
Nearly 4.5 lakh passengers benefited from bike taxis in Karnataka, the aggregators submitted. They relied on an earlier unchallenged High Court ruling and Central government notifications issued in 2004 and 2024.
The Centre confirmed that motorcycles could be used as taxis under its notifications, in response to the bench’s query.
The Court dismissed the State’s appeal after considering the submissions.












