New Delhi: While directing Shiv Sena (UBT) MP Sanjay Raut to exercise restraint in his choice of words, the Supreme Court, on Tuesday, observed that a seasoned politician who has spent several years in Parliament should know the importance of measured public statements.
The bench of Justice Arvind Kumar and Justice Vipul M Pancholi was hearing of criminal contempt proceedings initiated against Raut and journalist Nikhil Wagle over their remarks and social media posts concerning Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant and the Indian judiciary.
Raut appeared physically before the court on Tuesday, and Wagle joined virtually, as directed by the Court during the previous hearing.
Both respondents were then directed to file additional and more elaborate affidavits explaining their remarks and addressing the issues raised by the court, along with the unconditional apologies already tendered by them for their conduct, as reported by ANI.
The Court also directed both to remain physically present at the next hearing on December 8 at 2 pm.
“But in a matter of this magnitude and nature, Sanjay Raut, you are a seasoned politician. We have been hearing your political debates even during our advocate days. You have been in Parliament for so many years. You should know what restraint you ought to exercise in your words,” the bench told Raut.
The Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA), represented by its president and senior advocate Pradeep Rai argued that Raut, by virtue of being a respected public figure and a responsible MP, should not be pardoned for his repeated derogatory remarks.
Two contempt proceedings against Raut were already pending before the Bombay High Court, Rai pointed out and argued that the present remarks could not be viewed in isolation. It was further submitted that the Shiv Sena (UBT) leader had made further social media posts even after submitting his apology affidavit.
Rai referred to a post in which Raut had shared an image of the Supreme Court of Albania on fire, raising concerns about the nature of the message being conveyed.
He had no justification to offer for his client’s remarks, a senior counsel appearing for Raut informed the Court.
“The only answer I have today is that he has offered an unconditional, unqualified apology,” the lawyer submitted.
The bench, however, took note of the subsequent posts and statements and indicated that these would also have to be addressed.
Senior advocate Indira Jaising, appearing for Wagle, submitted that her client had expressed genuine remorse over the post, which had been deleted immediately by him and had tendered an unconditional apology to the Attorney General as well as the Supreme Court. Wagle had been a professional journalist for five decades and had never faced such proceedings earlier, she said.
Her client had approached the courts in the past seeking protection of fundamental rights and had always maintained respect for the judicial institution, Jaising further highlighted.
Wagle’s work was driven by public interest and he held the press in high regard, it was submitted.
The bench, however, asked the counsel to ensure that Wagle specifically addressed two other tweets in his additional affidavit.
“It is in bad taste even for us to repeat it,” the bench observed, referring to the language used in the posts.
Jaising clarified that she was not seeking to justify the language used by her client.
The controversy arose after CJI Surya Kant declined an in-person meeting with a delegation of Opposition leaders, including Rahul Gandhi and Mallikarjun Kharge, who had sought to discuss issues concerning the functioning of the Election Commission of India.
Following this, Wagle published an abusive post targeting the CJI on social media, which he subsequently deleted and apologised for.
Raut, meanwhile, made remarks alleging that judges of the Supreme Court and High Courts had attended political programmes organised by the BJP and that chief ministers had hosted dinners for judges. He also referred to photographs purportedly showing judges playing badminton with political leaders in London.
These statements were intended to undermine public confidence in the judiciary, the SCBA alleged. The Delhi High Court had earlier directed the removal of the disputed badminton photographs after finding that they did not depict an event in London as claimed.
The Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) subsequently initiated criminal contempt proceedings against the duo after obtaining the consent of Attorney General of India (AGI) R Venkataramani.
Emphasising the importance of journalism and its role in a democracy, she said the fourth pillar of democracy was held in the highest esteem and that she would never disown her association with the legal profession.
The court held the press in high esteem, the bench remarked. However, it directed Wagle to be present physically before the Court in the next hearing with an elaborate explanation for his tweets.
“Whatever he wants to say on this, an apology or whatever, let him put it in his affidavit,” the bench said. It wanted to bring the proceedings to a close after considering the explanations offered by both respondents, the bench said.
“We want to put a quietus to it. We will see what they want to argue,” Justice Kumar said. A comprehensive order would be passed on the next date of hearing, it said.














