• Latest
  • Trending
  • All
  • Sport
  • Cricket
  • Odisha
supreme court hybrid hearing in delhi pollution

‘She Didn’t See It As Crime’: SC Frees Man Convicted Under POCSO Using Article 142

1 year ago
Odisha Girl Tops Nation In ITI Exam; To Be Felicitated By PM

Odisha Girl Tops Nation In ITI Exam; To Be Felicitated By PM

6 minutes ago
Cyclone Akvan Weakens Into Deep Depression Over South Coastal Odisha

Cyclone Akvan Weakens Into Deep Depression Over South Coastal Odisha

21 minutes ago
Traffic Curbs In Bhubaneswar, Kataka For President Murmu’s 2-Day Odisha Visit; Check Details

Traffic Curbs In Bhubaneswar, Kataka For President Murmu’s 2-Day Odisha Visit; Check Details

32 minutes ago
“Update Your Picture Of India”, Jaishankar Urges Japanese Businesses

“Update Your Picture Of India”, Jaishankar Urges Japanese Businesses

56 minutes ago
Congress MLA Tara Bahinipati Threatens Self-Immolation Inside Odisha Assembly For Discussion On Kotia

Congress MLA Tara Bahinipati Threatens Self-Immolation Inside Odisha Assembly For Discussion On Kotia

1 hour ago
NTA Removes 600 Subject Matter Experts, Starts Fresh Empanelment

NTA Removes 600 Subject Matter Experts, Starts Fresh Empanelment

2 hours ago
Odisha Assembly Adjourned Till Nov 23 In View Of Cyclone Akvan

Odisha Assembly Adjourned Till Nov 23 In View Of Cyclone Akvan

2 hours ago
Odisha Shifts 3.72L To Safety As Cyclone Akvan Makes Landfall, Situation Under Control, Says Govt

Odisha Shifts 3.72L To Safety As Cyclone Akvan Makes Landfall, Situation Under Control, Says Govt

2 hours ago
Islam Will Surpass Christianity As Largest Religion By 2035: Pew Research Centre

Islam Will Surpass Christianity As Largest Religion By 2035: Pew Research Centre

3 hours ago
Heavy Rain Batters Odisha As Cyclone Akvan Makes Landfall, Ganjam’s Patrapur Records Highest 209 MM

Heavy Rain Batters Odisha As Cyclone Akvan Makes Landfall, Ganjam’s Patrapur Records Highest 209 MM

3 hours ago
Paradip Port Provides Shelter To Fishermen; Coast Guard On Standby

Paradip Port Provides Shelter To Fishermen; Coast Guard On Standby

3 hours ago
TPNODL Strengthens Cyclone Preparedness Across Northern Odisha; Issues Public Safety Advisory

TPNODL Strengthens Cyclone Preparedness Across Northern Odisha; Issues Public Safety Advisory

3 hours ago
  • Home
  • About us
  • Career
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Usage
Friday, November 20, 2026
No Result
View All Result
OdishaBytes
  • Home
  • Odisha
    • Policy & Politics
    • City
  • India
  • Sport
    • Cricket
    • Football
    • Hockey
    • IPL
  • Entertainment
    • Music
    • Movie Review
    • Television
    • Bollywood
    • Hollywood
    • Ollywood
  • Business
  • Lifestyle
    • Travel
    • Food
    • Health
    • fashion
  • World
  • More
    • News You Can Use
    • Good News
    • Viral Videos
    • Tech
      • Cars & Bikes
      • Mobile & Gadgets
      • Review
  • Home
  • Odisha
    • Policy & Politics
    • City
  • India
  • Sport
    • Cricket
    • Football
    • Hockey
    • IPL
  • Entertainment
    • Music
    • Movie Review
    • Television
    • Bollywood
    • Hollywood
    • Ollywood
  • Business
  • Lifestyle
    • Travel
    • Food
    • Health
    • fashion
  • World
  • More
    • News You Can Use
    • Good News
    • Viral Videos
    • Tech
      • Cars & Bikes
      • Mobile & Gadgets
      • Review
No Result
View All Result
OdishaBytes
No Result
View All Result
Home India

‘She Didn’t See It As Crime’: SC Frees Man Convicted Under POCSO Using Article 142

by OB Bureau
May 23, 2025
in India
Reading Time: 3 mins read
supreme court hybrid hearing in delhi pollution
491
SHARES
1.4k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

New Delhi: In a landmark judgment invoking extraordinary constitutional powers under Article 142, the Supreme Court on Friday freed a man convicted of sexual relations with a minor, ruling that further punishment would not serve the cause of justice given the unique circumstances of the case.

The bench of Justice Abhay S. Oka and Justice Ujjal Bhuyan delivered a nuanced verdict, noting that the victim—now the man’s wife—did not view the act as a crime, and had suffered more from the legal fallout than from the act itself.

ADVERTISEMENT

“Society Judged Her, System Failed Her”

The apex court emphasized the emotional bond between the victim and the accused, highlighting that they now live together with their child in West Bengal.

“The victim didn’t treat this as a heinous crime. Society judged her, the legal system failed her, and her family abandoned her,” the court said.
“What she had to face as a consequence was not just the act, but the police, the legal system, and the constant battle to save the accused from punishment.”

The case, the court noted, underscored significant gaps in the legal system’s treatment of adolescent relationships and victims’ autonomy.

Background of the Case

The incident dates back to 2018, when the girl, then 14 years old, went missing and was later found to have married a 25-year-old man.

A complaint by her family led to the man’s conviction under the POCSO Act and a 20-year prison sentence by a local court.

In 2023, the Calcutta High Court controversially acquitted the man, making contentious remarks about adolescent sexuality and societal morality.

The High Court’s view drew severe public backlash and prompted Supreme Court intervention.

Supreme Court’s Review and Decision

In August 2024, the Supreme Court reinstated the man’s conviction, reversing the High Court’s decision but withheld sentencing, ordering the West Bengal government to form an expert panel to assess the victim’s current psychological and social well-being.

The panel—comprising psychologists and child welfare experts—submitted a report noting the victim’s emotional attachment to the accused and her strong sense of family loyalty.

Based on the findings, the court held that sentencing the man now would harm the victim more and disrupt a family unit that has since formed.

Use of Article 142: “Complete Justice”

The court invoked Article 142 of the Constitution, which empowers it to pass any order necessary to do complete justice in any case before it.

“She did not have the opportunity to make an informed choice earlier. The system failed her at multiple levels,” the bench remarked.

By using Article 142, the court has exempted the accused from serving the prison term, despite upholding his conviction.

Broader Implications and Legal Commentary

This verdict is poised to reignite national discourse on:

The implementation of the POCSO Act, especially in cases involving consensual adolescent relationships.

The limitations of the legal system in protecting vulnerable minors from both exploitation and post-crisis trauma.

The need for policy updates to reflect socio-cultural realities, especially where victims wish to reclaim their agency and rebuild their lives.

The case is now being seen as an “eye-opener”, in the court’s own words, with potential to inform future reforms in juvenile and sexual offense jurisprudence.

Article 142 of the Indian Constitution

What is Article 142?

Article 142 of the Constitution of India empowers the Supreme Court to pass any decree or make any order necessary for doing “complete justice” in any matter pending before it. This unique provision enables the apex court to transcend limitations posed by statutory laws when equity and justice demand an extraordinary remedy.

Key Features:

It is a plenary power vested only in the Supreme Court.

It ensures the primacy of justice over procedural limitations.

It allows the court to fashion remedies that may not exist in statute.

Notable Previous Invocations:

Union Carbide case (Bhopal Gas Tragedy): To ensure relief and compensation.

Ayodhya land dispute: To effect a settlement beyond strict legal boundaries.

In the Current Case:

By invoking Article 142, the court upheld the man’s conviction but suspended his sentence, balancing legal integrity with human complexity. This reflects how Article 142 can help align the rigid letter of the law with the broader spirit of justice.

Comparative Look: POCSO Act Precedents and Challenges

Overview of POCSO:

The Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act, 2012, is a stringent law intended to protect minors from sexual abuse. It criminalizes all sexual activity with persons below 18, irrespective of consent.

Precedent Tensions:

In State v. XYZ (Delhi High Court), a consensual relationship between teens resulted in conviction due to strict statutory interpretation.

In Independent Thought v. Union of India (2017), the Supreme Court read down the marital rape exception for minors.

Challenges Revealed:

Zero tolerance framework clashes with consensual adolescent relationships.

The act does not differentiate between exploitation and romantic relationships, causing punitive outcomes even where the minor asserts autonomy.

Judicial discretion is constrained, often leaving no room for socio-cultural nuance.

Current Judgment’s Implication:

This Supreme Court ruling does not dilute the statute but introduces a compassionate jurisprudential lens. It recognizes that applying the law uniformly may victimize those it intends to protect—especially in emotionally bonded relationships.

Share196Tweet123
ADVERTISEMENT
Previous Post

Odisha Govt Inks MoU With PhonePe To Digitally Empower Startups

Next Post

India, Pakistan Extend Closure Of Airspace For Each Other’s Airlines By A Month

OB Bureau

OB Bureau

Related Posts

“Update Your Picture Of India”, Jaishankar Urges Japanese Businesses

“Update Your Picture Of India”, Jaishankar Urges Japanese Businesses

by OB Bureau
November 20, 2026

New Delhi: External affairs minister S Jaishankar, during his recent visit to Japan, urged businesses there to update their perception...

NTA Removes 600 Subject Matter Experts, Starts Fresh Empanelment

NTA Removes 600 Subject Matter Experts, Starts Fresh Empanelment

by OB Bureau
November 20, 2026

New Delhi: In a major overhaul of its system, the National Testing Agency (NTA) has removed around 600 subject matter...

Chhota Shakeel Aide Gunned Down By Police In UP

Chhota Shakeel Aide Gunned Down By Police In UP

by OB Bureau
November 20, 2026

Bulandshahr: Days after killing of a 26-year-old man outside Delhi law minister Kapil Mishra's office on November 16, notorious gangster...

Delhi HC

Aadhaar Alone Cannot Prove Date Of Birth, Rules Delhi High Court

by OB Bureau
November 19, 2026

New Delhi: Aadhaar card cannot independently serve as conclusive proof of an individual’s date of birth, the Delhi High Court...

Next Post
India, Pakistan extend ban on airspaces

India, Pakistan Extend Closure Of Airspace For Each Other’s Airlines By A Month

OMC-Ad OMC-Ad OMC-Ad
SAI International School SAI International School SAI International School
OdishaBytes

Copyright © 2026 Frontier Media

Navigate Site

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact
  • News Feed

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Odisha
    • Policy & Politics
    • City
  • India
  • Sport
    • Cricket
    • Football
    • Hockey
    • IPL
  • Entertainment
    • Music
    • Movie Review
    • Television
    • Bollywood
    • Hollywood
    • Ollywood
  • Business
  • Lifestyle
    • Travel
    • Food
    • Health
    • fashion
  • World
  • More
    • News You Can Use
    • Good News
    • Viral Videos
    • Tech
      • Cars & Bikes
      • Mobile & Gadgets
      • Review

Copyright © 2026 Frontier Media